Tags
alternate juror, Anniversary, civil duty, deliberations, honor, Immigrant, Judicial system, jury duty, learning self control, White Plains
“Ask not what your country can do for you; ask what you can do for your country.” ― John F. Kennedy
My future began today, 30 years ago! Today is the anniversary of my arrival in the US. I arrived in NY November 8, 1984 to stay 3 months. 30 years later I am still here and I can’t imagine ever leaving it.
It has been 30 years of amazing experiences. There have been tough times and fun times. There has been immense growth, but in some ways I am still the 17 year clueless girl that arrived unsure of what the future would hold. I had no English, no money, no job and had bills to pay, but I had one powerful ally on my side: My unshakable belief in God!
I will not go into details about my arrival here and the life I have lived these 30 years on this post. I plan to write about it in the future when inspiration and time permits. The point of today’s post is to tell you about the gift that NY State has given me to celebrate my anniversary: I was chosen as Alternate Juror Number One in a Medical Malpractice case!
I find it poetic to be doing this right at this milestone of 30 years. I am choosing to see this as an honor and also as my right and duty as an American citizen. I also get to witness first hand how the American Justice system works.
Well, at first, like everyone else, I tried to get out of jury duty. I was not going to lie to get out of it, but I figured that my brutal honesty would perhaps be enough.
In case you have never been called for jury duty let me give you a brief summary of what happened when I showed up in court 2 days ago. I was instructed to sit in this huge auditorium with another approximately 100 people. The Commissioner of Jurors addressed us and explained all that was going to happen. I found her and her assistant extremely helpful and friendly. Then they dismissed some people such as students that would be missing school, people that had vacation scheduled, people with difficulty in understanding the English language, etc. From there we were divided in smaller groups. Each group went into a separate room and got assigned a case. My group was assigned a Medical Malpractice case. They then introduced both attorneys, the one for the plaintiff and the one for the defendant. In this case the plaintiff herself was also present, but not the defendant. The attorney then explained the case and asked every single one of us questions while looking at questionnaire that we each had completed upon arrival.
The aim of these questions are to make sure that there is nothing in our lives (or in the lives of our loved ones) that may make difficult for us to be partial when deliberating, such as legal issue, medical issues, etc. For example, a lady was dismissed because her husband was a patient at the clinic where this one doctors works.
They questioned us in groups of 12. After each group the attorneys go to a separate room and decide on who to pick and who to send home. From the first group of the 12, they chose only 3 people. We were all shocked that some of the people that we thought would clearly be chosen was not, while some that we thought would never be picked were. From the second group of 12, my group, 4 people were chosen. From the final 12 people another 2 were chosen.
“Human happiness and moral duty are inseparably connected.” ― George Washington
When it was my turn to be questioned, I answered honestly and provided information such as:
- I come from a country where people don’t sue people and then I get to the US and everyone here is sue-happy. I don’t really like all this suing business. To which the attorney asked me if I would be able to see that some suits have merits. I said: of course.
- My brother is a nurse and I have heard plenty of horror stories about some doctors’s carelessness.
- I have had both good and bad experiences with doctors. To which the attorney said if that meant that I would be able to see both sides, the patient and the doctor and form an opinion. I said yes.
- If chosen I will have to work some evenings and on the weekend to be able to catch up with my work, as I am the only one in my company that does what I do, such a payroll, etc. To that one of the attorneys asked me jokingly if I was trying to play the “Jewish mother guilt card”.
- One of the attorneys asked if I would be open to the idea that doctors can make a mistake, and if so if I would be able to award monetary damages. I responded that I would be open to anything, I would have to hear the facts and see the evidence in the case. He liked that answer.
- I said that they should ask jurors for their astrological signs. I am serious! The way the jurors interact with one another is very important. I don’t think the attorneys took that seriously.
- I also mentioned, and this may have been my biggest mistake, that it would be my 30th year anniversary of living in the US, and as such I saw this entire “being called for jury process” an honor.
My question and answer part drew laughs and even applause, but still I didn’t expect to be chosen. I was shocked when they called my name, and yet there was part of me that knew I was going to be called. It is hard to describe, knowing that something will happen and at the same time being shocked when it does.
I accept it and I will perform it to the best of my abilities.
Here is what I see as the worst part of it all: I am an alternate juror. As such I have to sit there and listen to the evidence but when it comes time to deliberate I get send home with the thanks from the court. In a way it feels like punishment for me, since I always have something to say about everything. We have only heard one day of testimony and I am already in pins and needles with so much to say.
In this case there are 6 jurors and 3 alternates. The order in which you are picked dictates your juror number. I was the 7th person chosen, that is why I get to be Alternate number one. Being alternate juror number 1 means I am number 1 on the reserve bench. I only get to play if one of the main players gets injured or some other emergency happens.
“Character is doing what you don’t want to do but know you should do.” ― Joyce Meyer
This whole thing will be an incredible learning experience. Here are some of the benefits I already see about becoming a juror, and this case an alternate juror.
- New friends. I have already become fast friends with 3 amazing ladies. One is a teacher, one is an attorney and one is a very social retiree. I can see continuing the friendship(s) once this is over. All the other jurors are also friendly.
- Learning to be quiet and just absorb the information and keep my opinions to myself will be hard, but I am sure it is something that I can learn and use it in my daily life. Just the other day my co-worker said to me: Just because I am telling you something it does not mean I want your opinion or advice! Ouch! But he was right!
- Learning to refrain from impulsively researching on Google and looking for information about people/things. As jurors, we are not allowed to research aspects and the subjects of the case. Do you know how hard it is for me not to Google this doctor and this medical condition? Extremely hard since I am a Googleholic (I guess I just made up a word :-).
- Learning that I have to have faith and trust in others to make the right decision. I guess I do have a massive ego and I also have very high self esteem. It has crossed my mind that the 6 jurors may not make the right decision without my valuable input. How egotistical of me! Why do I always think I am either the smartest person in the room or the dumbest? Why can I think of me as average?
- Not having the pressure to make a decision. Well, this one was pointed to me as a benefit but I am not sure. I don’t see it as pressure in this case but mostly making justice. Now, if this was criminal court and somebody’s freedom was in my hands I probably would have a different opinion.
At the end of the day I am there to perform my duties of Alternate Juror Number One to the best of my abilities. I am going to be the juror that I wish would be listening to my case were I a defendant or a plaintiff in a case. Golden Rule always!
So far we have heard one day of testimony. I cannot write about the details right now, but at the end I will and I will also let you know if I agree or not with the jurors, not that it matters either way! 😦
“Patriotism is not short, frenzied outbursts of emotion, but the tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime.” ― Adlai E. Stevenson II
Wow, you are brave. I wouldn’t like to decide one way or the other. I am guessing that in this case, because it’s medical malpractice, someone could have died because of it, and that other people’s lives will be in the hands of this doctor and so it could be a life or death situation. I would instinctively air on the side of the patient, because I have had some bad experiences with doctor’s, but not all have been bad. I am a big believer in alternative medicine. I bet the others are Googling this case.
LikeLike
I may not have to decide since I am just an alternate, but still I have to pay attention just in case. I have had bad experiences with doctors, but also good ones. I am also a big believer in alternative medicine! Blessings! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s great. My own Doctor doesn’t believe in alternative medicine. He had me on 8 pills a day for a digestive problem. I had to go to hospital last December and had a month of work. To cut a long story short, what I had damaged the lining of my stomach and I went back to work, still with problems. In March, he said he couldn’t do anything else for me. I did my own research into the problem and came to the conclusion that my digestive enzymes weren’t working anymore. I told the doctor this and that I think I may need to take digestive enzymes. He disagreed. I now take 2 digestive enzymes every day and have chamomile and ginger tea, that has licorice root. My digestion is normal again. I can actually digest more things than I used to before I went to hospital. I will have to do this forever though.
LikeLike
I am glad that you found a solution to your digestive problem, even though it is something you will have to do it forever. Perhaps it won’t be forever, our bodies change.. I believe that we know our own bodies better than anyone, so we should take a doctor’s conclusion but also listen to our bodies.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Star, thank you so much for your kind comments. I think I have been lacking in the digestive enzyme department for a while. Now I can digest more foods than I used to before I was taken ill.
LikeLike
It is wonderful that you were able to come up with your own diagnosis and medicate yourself! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Star. My appreciated.
LikeLike
🙂 any time! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I meant much appreciated – Late nights.
LikeLike
I was indeed wondering how many hours you sleep every night – you get so much done!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Last night was only 2 hours sleep because I launched my new http://www.quirkyacademy.com site. I am very tired tonight so need to sleep soon.
LikeLike
2 hours!!! I would be a zombie. Best of luck with the site!:-)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have been called to jury duty this week. I am going to fill in the ‘I cannot do this’ form as there is too much happening in my life.
Good luck with the court case that you get and your impartiality.
LikeLike
I could have postponed for 6 months, but I figured it was better to just get it over with it right now. Thank you and blessings! 🙂
LikeLike
Since reading your post and writing my comment, I applied and I managed to get a two-year exemption. Ah-ha! Hopefully my life will have settled by then 🙂
LikeLike
Good for you! perhaps in those 2 years they will lose your address! A settled life? is there such a thing? lol
Blessings!:-)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Interesting post.
LikeLike
Thank you! 🙂
LikeLike
I find it is a hard job, and I admire you. I cannot be called for service as I am not a British citizen, and funny enough I can to London 30 years ago too. How time flies and we have learnt a lot in those 30 years. May we learn a lot more and life give us more experience as we grow older. Bless you !
LikeLike
Hi Ute
Something else we have in common 🙂
Indeed there was a lot learning in the past 30 years for both of us. Let’s make sure the next 30 years are even better!
Thank you and blessings to you too! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Absolutely! They will be! 🙂
LikeLike
🙂
LikeLike
I’ve been called for jury duty twice but not selected. The reasons have been that I have a son in the military and a relative who was a policeman. As the wife of a physician who was sued in a case that was dismissed after only 45 minutes of deliberation, I wish you well. I felt sorry for the jurors who has to sit through 3 weeks of evidence production in what was a frivolous suit. Do MDs make mistakes? You bet! But so many suits are baseless.
LikeLike
I am trying not to think of anything but the specifics of the case, but it is hard. People seem to feel mostly for the plaintiff. I am the opposite, I always put myself in the position of someone being unfairly accused. So in this case I am trying to leave all that at the door and have an open mind to listen to all the facts first before forming an opinion. I agree there are just too many frivolous suits. Something bad happens, immediately people look for someone to blame/sue. 😦
LikeLike
Wonderful post. I’m really interested to hear your ‘how you got to NY’ story when you’re ready to tell it. Loved that you have taken the whole experience as an opportunity to learn: how wonderful. [Your way of thinking is such an inspiration!]
LikeLike
I will definitely write about it at some point – stay tuned!
As someone once said: “It is not what happens to you, but how you react to you it!”
It is not always easy but I continue to try to find a positive in everything,
Thank you and many blessings! 🙂
LikeLike
We’re definitely in tune: I’m of exactly the same opinion. Life is all about how we perceive, and react to, the things that we see and that happen to us.
LikeLike
🙂
LikeLike
You will like this report http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/berlin-wall-anniversary/bill-neely-berlin-walls-fall-was-greatest-story-i-ever-n240781
LikeLike
It was not meant for me, but I did! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Please ignore my last comment on the Berlin Wall – it wasn’t intended for you! Sorry! xx
LikeLike
Nothing to be sorry about it! It was not meant for me but I enjoyed reading it and watching it! 🙂
LikeLike
How interesting! You actually get to see first hand how the system works. This story is very insightful, informative.
LikeLike
It has been so interesting! I can’t wait to be over to be able to write about it! Thank you! Blessings! 🙂
LikeLike
This is insightful and informative. You had the privilege of seeing jurisprudence first hand.
LikeLike
What a great learning experience for you – an opportunity to examine your own judgmental processes, too! Very interesting post.
LikeLike
Indeed!! I am happy to be able to have this experience. Every day I learn something new! Blessings! 🙂
LikeLike
hadn’t thought about it, much: but thanx to your story I AM REMINDED: basically, i enjoyed my two experiences as a juror!
the first time i was (s)elected as foreman (“fore-person” eh?) — i practiced clearing my throat to be able to answer (‘has the jury reached a decision?”) — “YES WE HAVE, YOUR HONOR”.
LikeLike
You did it twice – good for you! I am sure it was exciting saying those words! Unfortunately I will not even be present at that moment because I am only an alternate juror, so I am a bit jealous of you ! Blessings! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
as alternate, there’s a good chance you will replace someone …
LikeLike
there is this one older lady that keeps coughing so I jokingly said to her: “every time you cough I am one step closer to being a full blown juror” 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
What a great story about your journey through our justice system! Thank you for sharing and you write very well!
LikeLike
Thank you so much for reading and enjoying it! Readers and fellow bloggers like you keep me motivated to write more! Blessings! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Do you get paid for this ?
LikeLike
The rate is $40.00 per day, but you only get paid if your employer doesn’t pay you for those days. By law if your employers has more then 10 employees he has to pay. Students, people unemployed, retired, stay at home moms, etc get paid. Therefore I will not see a dime.
LikeLiked by 1 person